EUREKA DESIGN PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITEDSET: UREKA🇹🇭 TH

Internal Control · 2024

Internal Control — Board Opinion

Summary of the Board's Opinion on Internal Control

The Board of Directors has established an effective risk management and internal control system in accordance with relevant laws and standards.

Company Practices

1. The Board of Directors shall ensure that the Board of Directors has knowledge and understanding of the key risks in conducting business.

2. The Board of Directors shall perform the following:

- Establish policies and a risk management system for the Group.

- Promote risk management as an integral part of the Group's key culture.

- The Group has appropriate risk management, with an emphasis on early warning signs.

- Monitor, supervise, and evaluate the performance

3. The Board of Directors shall have an internal audit function. The Audit Committee shall determine the qualifications, recruit, and select the internal audit function, which shall report to the Audit Committee on the following matters:

- Review the Group's appropriate internal control system.

- Review and establish internal control measures, focusing on significant irregularities.

Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System

Internal Control Framework Used

FrameworkDetail
The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO)

Internal Audit Policy

In 2023, the Company hired JR Business Advisory Company Limited (JR) to audit the adequacy and effectiveness of the Company's internal control system to provide reasonable assurance that the Company's management and operations are in accordance with good corporate governance principles and that there are adequate and appropriate internal controls and risk management, as well as to provide recommendations for system improvement and report to the Audit Committee on a quarterly basis.

JR has assessed the risks and prepared an annual internal audit plan, conducted audits, provided recommendations, and monitored the system improvement on a quarterly basis and reported directly to the Audit Committee for the benefit of corporate governance as prescribed by the Stock Exchange of Thailand. The latest internal audit report summarized the results of the internal control assessment of the Company and its subsidiaries for the year 2023, which can be summarized as follows:

1. Assessment of the adequacy of the internal control system at the organizational level

The assessment will cover 5 elements of internal control as follows:

• Control Environment

• Risk Management

• Control Activity

• Information & Communication

• Monitoring

2. Assessment of the adequacy of the internal control system in accordance with the Anti-Corruption Standards

• Revenue and Collection System

• Procurement and Disbursement System

Internal Control Deficiencies

Number of Deficiencies

MetricCurrent YearPrevious YearTwo Years Ago
Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases)396

Deficiency Details

Period TypeStart Period (YYYY-MM)End Period (YYYY-MM)DetailProgress StatusCorrective Action
Within (month/year)2023-122023-12
1. Revenue and Collection System 1. The Company has not yet established a business plan to serve as a framework for marketing planning, financial planning, and management of each business line, such as business objectives, performance projections, strategies, and budgets in writing.
Incident no longer subject to action

1. Set clear revenue targets, including an action plan to achieve the set targets.

2. A comparative report of the operating results against the financial estimates is prepared to examine and compare actual income and expenses with the operating plan, including an analysis of the operating results. Implementation period: 1 January 2024

Person responsible: Production Department and Accounting and Finance Department

Within (month/year)2023-122023-12
2. The Company Group should consider reviewing and implementing the following: 2.1) Establish a clear written structure, roles, responsibilities, and accountabilities for each business line that aligns with the nature of the current business operations.
Implemented

1. Responsibilities are assigned appropriately to the business line.

2. The current Job Description for each position requires the employee to acknowledge their duties and responsibilities with a signature, along with the approval signature of the head of the department.


Implementation period: 1 January 2024 Person in charge: Human Resources Department and related departments


This has been rectified.

Within (month/year)2023-122023-12
2.2) Define responsibilities, including the development of job descriptions (Job Description) by assigning responsibilities for each position to be up-to-date and consistent with the organizational structure.
Implemented

Currently, the company requires a review of the Job Description within the first quarter of the year. If there are any changes in the structure or personnel, the department head will review and revise the Job Description to be appropriate for the employee and send it to the employee for acknowledgement.


Implementation period: 1 January 2024

Person in charge: Human Resources Department and related departments


The revision has been completed.

Within (month/year)2023-122023-12
3. The Company Group should review and proceed with the following matters: 3.1) Accounting practices are not aligned with current operations due to the parent company's business restructuring. 3.2) Criteria/conditions/operating procedures for the sales process (revenue generation) of each business line (company) are not clearly defined or documented. 3.3) Each subsidiary has a different business model. In particular, A.P.W. has a large international customer base with different sales and payment processes compared to domestic sales.
Implemented

Currently reviewing the operational manuals of each company to align with their respective business models.


Timeline: Expected completion within the second quarter of 2024.


Person in charge: Finance and Accounting Department


The issue has been resolved.

Within (month/year)2023-122023-12
4. Further consideration should be given to enhancing controls over the operational process of sales at A.P.W. International Co., Ltd. (APW). 4.1) APW's sales process does not involve the issuance of quotations, customer purchase orders, or sales orders. The company utilizes COMMERCIAL INVOICES in lieu of sales orders for all transactions. This practice stems from the majority of clients being long-standing and international customers with ongoing transactions and verbal confirmations at the executive level, eliminating the need for formal sales documents and contracts. However, the use of COMMERCIAL INVOICES lacks oversight by authorized personnel in the sales process, as they are not required to sign off on every invoice.
Incident no longer subject to action

Require customers to sign the quotation document for every sale.


Implementation period: Expected to be completed within the 1st quarter of 2024


Person responsible: Company's sales department

Within (month/year)2023-122023-12
4.2) The recording of revenue from foreign sales of A.P.W. International Co., Ltd. lacks supporting documents for referencing the exchange rate (Sport rate) announced by commercial banks for 30 transactions, totaling 66,788,493.78 baht. Additionally, the recording of exchange rate gains (losses) on the date of receipt using the net settlement method between the amount set on the sales date and the payment date resulted in a net profit (loss) of 9 and 22 transactions, with outstanding balances of 47,692,134.47 baht and 48,337,807.00 baht received, respectively (as detailed in Annex 1). The difference from the recognized exchange rate gain (loss) is 645,672.53 baht, which pertains to foreign sales. This is because foreign customers settle payments for goods by depositing cash into the company's account in Thailand and sending a copy of the pay-in slip to the company. As a result, the company is unaware of the exchange rate used by the customer, as they do not provide exchange rate documentation. Moreover, there are 2 transactions on the date of receipt that were not recorded for profit (loss) as in the above cases, with an outstanding balance of 3,982,179.77 baht and a net receipt of 3,982,180 baht.
Implemented

Every time a payment is received, the customer must be informed of the bank's exchange rate used for the payment, along with every deposit slip.


Implementation period: Expected to be completed within Quarter 1/2024


Person in charge: Company sales department


This has been resolved.

Within (month/year)2023-122023-12
5. All credit note issuances were authorized by the Chief Financial Officer (CFO). Credit notes were sequentially numbered, and reasons for issuance were documented. However, these procedures were solely accounting-focused, lacking documented sales department approval prior to credit note issuance by the accounting department.
Incident no longer subject to action

A request for debt reduction/goods return approval must be prepared by the sales department and sent to authorized personnel for review and approval. This is then sent to the accounting department for consideration of issuing a debt reduction note and for further approval according to the authorization level.


Implementation Period: 1 January 2024

Responsible Person: Sales and Finance Department

Within (month/year)2023-122023-12
As of the audit date, Ureka Design Public Company Limited had 41 overdue accounts receivable balances outstanding for more than 120-365 days, totaling 1.31 million baht. Additionally, there were 36 accounts receivable balances overdue for more than 365 days, amounting to 7.08 million baht. These overdue balances represent 14.27% and 76.98%, respectively, of the total outstanding receivables, which the company needs to expedite collection efforts.
Incident no longer subject to action

1. A report on long-overdue accounts receivable is prepared and the outstanding balance is submitted to the management report every month.

2. Follow-up and collection of outstanding receivables from the subsidiary company, of which some were paid back in 2016. Other debtors are being followed up on and reported to the executives for further legal action.


Implementation Period: Corrective action has been taken since the date the issue was acknowledged and has been ongoing since January 1, 2023.


Responsible Person: Accounting and Finance Department

Within (month/year)2023-122023-12
2. Procurement and Payment System 1. The Group lacks a formal written annual budget for each business unit (company) as a tool for controlling and reporting expenses. (Discussions with the CFO revealed that in 2023, the Group has established steps to establish a budget framework. The Group is currently in the process of collecting data on each type of expense to be used as statistics for setting the annual budget.)
Incident no longer subject to action

1. Require the preparation of departmental budgets to control and monitor expenses to be more appropriate for the operations of each department.

2. Require the accounting department to prepare a report comparing actual expenses with the approved budget to control and monitor the company's operations.


Implementation period: Corrections have been implemented since the issue was acknowledged and are expected to be 100% effective from January 1, 2024.


Person in charge: All relevant departments that utilize the company's budget and the Finance and Accounting Department.

Within (month/year)2023-122023-12
2. The operations of A.P.W. International Co., Ltd. have areas that should be reviewed to enhance the effectiveness of the internal control system, including: 2.1) Procurement (Recycled Plastic): There is no annual or monthly procurement plan for raw materials/goods. Additionally, for all purchase orders of goods (recycled plastic), upfront payments are made equal to the total value of the goods. 2.2) Service Procurement: The company does not issue service request forms for control and documentation of service engagements.
Incident no longer subject to action

For forecasting orders and sales, the management team has a plan to manage the risk of estimation. The products sold are in market demand and have a consistent customer base who regularly purchase from the company. This consistent order pattern is used as a basis for estimation. Additionally, customers are consulted about their purchasing plans for each year.

Implementation period: Implemented from the date of acknowledgement.


Responsible person: Management and Sales department.

Within (month/year)2023-122023-12
3. Modern Synergy Company Limited's operations have areas that warrant review to enhance the effectiveness of its internal control system, specifically: 3.1) Duplicate purchase order numbers were issued in January 2026. Two purchase orders used the sequential number 11. This occurred because the operator manually assigned the sequential number for the purchase orders in the system instead of utilizing the system's automatic sequential numbering functionality.
Incident no longer subject to action

1. Specify that the purchase order number in the Express program is automatically numbered.

2. The purchase order preparer shall prepare a purchase order register for the accounting department to inspect.

Implementation period: Implementation of corrections from the date of acknowledgment of the issue and 100% completion starting from January 1, 2023.


Responsible person: Project Coordinator, Accounting

Within (month/year)2023-122023-12
3.2) Discrepancies were found in 7 instances where credit terms stated on quotations, purchase orders, and invoices from suppliers did not match.
Incident no longer subject to action

1. Assign an auditor to review purchase order details and approve them before every purchase.

2. Review purchase order reports at the end of each month.

Implementation Period: 1 January 2024


Person in Charge: Project Coordinator, Accounting

Within (month/year)2024-122024-12
The company has not yet established a Record of Processing Activities (ROPA) for each department as required by the PDPA law, Sections 39(1), (2), (4), (5), and (8), which mandates clear written documentation. This is due to the absence of a risk assessment to mitigate PDPA-related risks.
Incident no longer subject to action

The company has a personal data protection policy and announced the appointment of a Data Protection Officer in 2022 for data processing activities. The company has already organized it according to the attached documents. In this regard, the company has set up a PDPA task force, effective from January 10, 2023, and has carried out ROPA activities of the Human Resources, IT, and Accounting departments in written form.

Within (month/year)2024-122024-12
2. The company lacks operational procedures to ensure that the Personal Data Protection Act (PDPA) is implemented correctly and comprehensively, including raising awareness and knowledge among company personnel. This includes: 1) A process to verify that personal data is used for the purposes stated in the privacy notice and data usage request forms. 2) A process for monitoring and reviewing PDPA operations and awareness. 3) A training plan to raise awareness of PDPA principles and operations among the working team and personnel within the company.
Implemented

The company has a work plan for the Human Resources and Administration Department, ED Group, for the years 2024-2026 in the area of training, providing knowledge/public relations. This work plan specifies providing knowledge about PDPA to employees. The training will be conducted through E-Learning, which is accessible to everyone, within the Program tiger soft. This is currently in progress, starting from February 2025 onwards.


Person in charge: Human Resources and Administration Department

Within (month/year)2024-122024-12
3. No rehearsals or reviews of contingency plans for situations likely to occur within the organization, as defined in the established emergency plan.
Implemented

The company has an internal control plan for information technology (IT) in the form of an IT system troubleshooting plan in case of an emergency.

(WI-IT-01) As per the attached document, the company has an Action Plan for review, referring to the Human Resources and Administration Division's Operational Plan for 2019-2020.


Responsible Person: Human Resources and Administration Division

Within (month/year)2022-122022-12
According to the Procurement Work Instruction (WI-PC-01) announced on November 4, 2021, the audit revealed the following issues: • There is no documented work instruction for the vendor review process. • There is no concrete procurement procedure, including price negotiation, price inquiry, bidding, and special methods. • There is no work instruction for goods receiving inspection planning, including procedures for handling shortages, overages, complimentary items, and daily inspection reports. • There is no documented procedure for document transfer between the project site and the head office. • There is no procedure for verifying product warranty information and maintaining a warranty registration log. • There is no procedure for product claims, including claim registration, log maintenance, and claim form documentation.
Implemented

The company plans to adjust various regulations and procedures due to changes in the business structure. This includes restructuring the organization, defining job positions and responsibilities, and developing a workforce plan for both the company and its subsidiaries, including authorization levels.


Expected completion: Within Quarter 4/2022

Responsible person: Line Management appointed to oversee each department will initiate the process under the supervision of the Executive Committee. The issue has been resolved.


The issue has been resolved.

Within (month/year)2022-122022-12
2. According to the Work Instruction for Procurement (WI-PC-01), issued on November 4, 2021, the audit revealed the following issues: • Absence of work instructions and procedures for reviewing vendor lists. • Lack of concrete procurement procedures, including price negotiation methods, price inquiry methods, bidding methods, and special procurement methods. • Absence of work instructions and procedures for preparing goods receiving plans, including procedures for handling shortages, surpluses, complimentary items, and daily receiving reports. • Lack of work instructions and procedures for document transfer between project sites and the head office. • Absence of work instructions and procedures for verifying product warranty information and maintaining warranty registration records. • Lack of work instructions and procedures for product claims, including claim registration, claim management, and claim documentation.
Implemented

The company plans to adjust various regulations and practices due to changes in the business structure. The company is currently restructuring its organization, identifying job positions, responsibilities, and manpower planning for both the company and its subsidiaries, including the authorization of approvals.


Expected completion: Within Quarter 4/2022

Person in charge: The appointed Line Management who oversees that department will initiate the process under the supervision of the Executive Committee.


The issue has been resolved.

Within (month/year)2022-122022-12
3. From the interview with the Chief Financial Officer (CFO) on June 24, 2022, regarding the authorization schedule and annual budget, it was acknowledged that the company is currently in the process of reviewing and making appropriate adjustments.
Implemented

The company plans to adjust practices in various areas due to changes in the business structure. The company is in the process of restructuring the organization, identifying job positions, responsibilities, and manpower planning for both the company and its subsidiaries, including approval authority.


Expected Completion: Within Quarter 4/2022

Responsible Person: Line Management appointed to oversee each department will initiate the process under the supervision of the Executive Committee.


The issue has been resolved.

Within (month/year)2022-122022-12
4. The CD Organizer system can automatically generate document numbers and dates for purchase orders, or users can manually enter them. In practice, the Project Co. officer (acting on behalf of the purchasing department) will verify the most recent purchase order number and date before choosing to automatically generate or manually enter the information. From the examination of purchase order (PO) numbering in the CD Organizer system from January 2022 to May 2022, it was found that from January 2022 to March 2022, purchase order (PO) numbers were sequential. However, in April 2022 and May 2022, the numbering was not sequential. The reason provided was due to urgent purchase orders, resulting in the issuance of backdated purchase orders (PO). Details are provided in Appendix Section 3.2.1.
Implemented

Acknowledged and will proceed with appropriate revisions.


Expected completion date: Within Quarter 4/2022

Person in charge: Chief Financial Officer


Currently completed.

Within (month/year)2022-122022-12
5. From a random audit of 17 payment vouchers between January 2022 and May 2022, the following was found: 1. Project Co. officers (acting on behalf of the procurement department) kept the original purchase orders (POs) at their department and sent copies to the accounting department. 2. The accounting department recorded two accruals as follows: • Purchase Order (PO2112007) for chlorine: The company received the goods on December 18, 2021, but recorded the payable (AP2204016) on April 1, 2022, for 83,460 baht. • Purchase Order (PO2112010) for chlorine: The company received the goods on December 24, 2021, but recorded the payable (AP2204017) on April 1, 2022, for 97,370 baht. See Appendix 3.2.2 for details.
Implemented

Acknowledge and will proceed with appropriate improvements.


Expected completion date: Within Quarter 4/2022

Person in charge: Chief Financial and Accounting Officer


The company has now completed the correction.

Within (month/year)2022-122022-12
6. The walk-through of the CD Organizer system revealed that all departments can access the system using the same credentials, without clearly defined access rights for each department.
Implemented

Acknowledged and will proceed with appropriate improvements.


Expected completion date: Within Quarter 4/2022

Person in charge: Chief Financial Officer


The issue has been resolved.

Within (month/year)2023-122023-12
3.3) Personal loans from directors were used to cover expenses at the Chonburi factory without going through the financial approval process. Additionally, there were high-value expenses without prior purchase requisitions/orders. For example, there were 8 instances of cash advances totaling 1.03 million baht between January and March 2023.
Incident no longer subject to action

The company requires each department to prepare work plans, purchase plans, and budgets before requesting payment authorization for all expenses. There may be some necessary advances that the management needs to approve for payment in advance. Currently, the company minimizes advances as much as it can control.


Implementation period: January 1, 2024

Responsible person: All departments involved in the company's budget and the finance and accounting department.

Audit Committee & Auditor Observations

Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's

No

Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control

No

Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

Head of Internal Audit

3160

Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

The Company has used the services of the Head of Internal Audit from an external agency since February 28, 2023, according to the resolution of the Audit Committee Meeting No. 1/2023 on February 28, 2023 until the present. JR Business Advisory Company Limited (JR Company) has been appointed to act as the Company's internal auditor, which JR Company has assigned Ms. Wanida Kanchansomtisak to be primarily responsible for performing the duties of the Company's internal auditor and has experience in internal audit work for more than 17 years. The details of the internal auditor are as follows:


JR Business Advisory Company Limited (JR Company) Address 288/123 Soi Phutthabucha 36, Phutthabucha Road, Bang Mot Subdistrict, Thung Khru District, Bangkok 10140

Head of Department : Ms. Wanida Kanchansomtisak


Position : Executive

Educational Qualifications Master of Business Administration (General Management), Ramkhamhaeng University

Bachelor of Business Administration (Accounting), Ramkhamhaeng University


Work Experience

1. Experience in auditing and evaluating internal control systems for a period of 17 years

2. Experience in accounting for a period of 19 years

Ms. Wanida Kanchansomtisak has more than 30 years of experience in auditing, internal control assessment, and accounting. She has experience as an executive of an internal audit and assessment company to find business risks and plan audits of real estate businesses, construction industry, transportation services, printing business, manufacturing industry, clean energy power plant rental services, TV and online media, plastic bag manufacturers, and packaging manufacturers, etc.


Summary of Training History and Qualifications

1. Certified Internal Auditor License CPIAT 527

2. Certified Internal Auditor CAC

3. Ethical Audit Course (2565)

4. Training “The Role of Internal Audit in Digital Fraud 2023”

5. Training “How Ready Are You for the Ministry of Public Health 38/2565”

6. Training “ISO Standards That Don't End with the Word Standard”

7. Training “Top Risks for Internal Audit 2023”


The Audit Committee has considered the qualifications of JR Business Advisory Company Limited (JR Company) and found it to be sufficiently qualified to perform such duties. Due to its independence and experience in internal audit work for more than 17 years, there is no conflict of interest and connection with the company.

Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit

Requires Audit Committee Approval

Yes

Description

The consideration and approval of the appointment, removal, or transfer of the Head of Internal Audit must be approved or consented to by the Audit Committee. The qualifications of the Head of Internal Audit are shown in Appendix 3.

Related Party Transactions

Has Related Party Transactions

Yes

Counterparties & Transactions

Monetary Unit

1000000

Counterparties with Potential Conflicts

NamePerson / Juristic PersonType of BusinessNature of RelationshipAs of Date (YYYY-MM-DD)
Modern Synergy Company LimitedJuristic PersonManufacturer and distributor of tap water

Modern Synergy Co., Ltd. is a subsidiary company.

2024-12-31T00:00
Eureka Energy Co., Ltd.Juristic PersonDevelop energy business

Eureka Energy Co., Ltd. is a subsidiary company.

2024-12-31T00:00
Ms. Rinnatha AkeassavapiromPerson

Senior Executives

2024-12-31T00:00

Transactions by Counterparty

Transactions
353914991.98 · Necessity: To be used for circulation in the company's business. · Description: 1. The Company provides human resources, accounting and monthly salary of 40,000 baht and monthly car rental of 18,000 baht. 2. In 2022, the subsidiary borrowed 399,065,970 baht from the Company to be used as working capital and invest in the construction of a water pipe system. 3. In 2023, the subsidiary borrowed additional 17,200,000 baht from the Company. The loan amount as of December 31, 2023 was 416,265,970 baht to invest in the construction of a water pipe system. The said loan is scheduled to bear interest at 7.40 percent, 6.84 percent, 5.89 percent and 4.77 percent, respectively, which is not lower than the current interest rate of loans from financial institutions. · As of yesteryear: 435562524.0 · Nature of transaction: 1. Other service income 2. Beginning loan receivables 3. Ending loan receivables 4. Interest receivable · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee has considered the related transactions of the Company and its subsidiaries with persons who may have conflicts of interest in the Audit Committee meeting and has given the opinion that the related transactions are reasonable. Prices and other conditions are set at market prices, the same as prices set for other unrelated persons or businesses. There is no benefit between the Company, its subsidiaries and persons who may have conflicts of interest. · As of year before yesteryear: 529635799.58
1376570.02 · Necessity: To be used for circulation in company activities · Description: 1. The Company provides human resource services in accounting and finance at 40,000 baht per month, car rental at 70,000 baht per month, and venue rental at 20,000 baht per month. 2. The subsidiary borrowed money from the Company to use as working capital in the business at an interest rate of 6.84 percent and 5.89 percent, which is not lower than the current interest rate of loans from financial institutions. The Company receives interest on loans to be used as working capital in the Company. · As of yesteryear: 2912880.92 · Nature of transaction: 1. Other service income 2. Income from purchasing production equipment 3. Loan receivables 4. Interest income · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee has considered the related transactions of the Company and its subsidiaries with persons who may have conflicts of interest in the Audit Committee meeting and has given the opinion that the related transactions are reasonable. Prices and other conditions are set at market prices, the same as prices set for other unrelated persons or businesses. There is no benefit between the Company, its subsidiaries and persons who may have conflicts of interest. · As of year before yesteryear: 1867558.74
35404149.45 · Necessity: To be used for circulation in the company's business. · Description: 1. The subsidiary company borrowed money from the executives to use as working capital in the business with an interest rate of 1.00 percent, which is equal to the current interest rate of 3-month fixed deposits from financial institutions. 2. Received interest on the loan to be used as working capital from the company. · As of yesteryear: 2605454.3 · Nature of transaction: 1. Director's loan at the beginning of the period Director's loan at the end of the period 2. Interest paid · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee has considered the related transactions of the Company and its subsidiaries with persons who may have conflicts of interest in the Audit Committee meeting and has given the opinion that the related transactions are reasonable. Prices and other conditions are set at market prices, the same as prices set for other unrelated persons or businesses. There is no benefit between the Company, its subsidiaries and persons who may have conflicts of interest. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
Contents